Ignoring climate change in Pakistan

Ignoring climate change


farmers of the Potohar region usually sow their wheat crop before November, and the agriculture department has set Nov 5 as the deadline for wheat sowing so that a better crop can be ensured. This year, though, with December nearly upon them, the farmers still find their land uncultivable.
“Sowing should begin possible by the end of December provided it does not rain too much,” says Mohammad Dorez, visibly distressed. Some eight kilometres to the west of Chakwal city, his grass-laden field is being ploughed. Dorez, who never had an education, does not know the expression ‘climate change’, but he blames his predicament on the unusual monsoon rains. In many parts of the region, there was very heavy rainfall up to October; but other parts of the region got lower than average rains.

Besides the delay in the sowing of wheat, the harvesting of the peanut crop — which is considered the sole cash crop in the region — has also been badly affected either by the unusual heavy rains, or the continued dry spell in the belt of Talagang, a tehsil of Chakwal district. The peanut crop should have been harvested three weeks ago but it is lying rotting in many fields because the drenched soil means the harvest cannot be undertaken.
“This is happening due to climate change,” says Dr Mohammad Tariq, director of the Barani Agricultural Research Institute in Chakwal.
Geographically, Pakistan is located in a region that is likely to be affected most by climate change. “As per vulnerability to climate change determined by Germanwatch [which compiles a climate change performance index], Pakistan is among the top 10 vulnerable countries in the world,” says Prof Dr Abdul Saboor, chairman of the department of economics and agri-economics at the Arid Agriculture University in Rawalpindi. “There is a continuous increase in temperature, due to which we have observed the heavy melting of ice, leading to floods in addition to a rise in sea level, which causes the degradation of mangroves in Pakistan. We have witnessed the devastating flood of 2010; the same pattern continued in subsequent years. Also, this rise in temperature is reflected in the drought in Sindh and Balochistan. Tharparkar is a classic case.”

A recent study conducted in Chakwal and Attock districts by Intercooperation, a Swiss non-governmental organisation, predicts horrible consequences of climate change. The report, jointly authored by Dr Mohammad Hanif, director of the Pakistan Meteorological Department, and Dr Jawad Ali, director of the Climate Change Centre of the University of Agriculture in Peshawar, predicts that the region is going to lose its spring and autumn seasons. “There will be only two seasons: summer and winter. The summers are going to be wet while the winters are turning into a dry season as we are facing an increase in summer rains and a decrease in winter rainfall,” says Dr Tariq, quoting the findings of the study. Due to the decrease in winter rains, the chances of the wheat crop failing are increasing while the crop has also become more prone to getting infested with weeds. The increase in summer rains means more soil erosion, more land degradation and more floods.
The agriculture sector, which is the backbone of Pakistan’s economy, is going to suffer badly. The change in the weather pattern is already having an impact on crops.

“The agricultural sector of this region is vulnerable to both temperature and rainfall,” says Dr Saboor. “The rise in temperature is hampering the per acre yield of the wheat and maize crops. There is also a serious impact on fruit and vegetables. The net farm revenue, as gauged from farming business, is the lowest in the region which is substantially attributed to climate change given all the other factors. There is an element of micro-climate change in the Barani region. For instance in Fateh Jang, it has been observed that some insects have started attacking livestock, thereby reducing the growth of animals and milk production. The frost phenomenon is also shaking the very fabric of plantation in some regions.”
But policymakers here don’t seem overly concerned. “India set up eight different institutions to tackle the climate change trend in 1971,” says an expert on agriculture. “But we have done nothing practical. We’ll be facing the worst sort of situation if we don’t take steps urgently.”

Ebola in Pakistan




A man who had recently returned from Togo, an Ebola-affected country in West Africa, and shown symptoms of the virus died on Tuesday at a hospital in Faisalabad.
Speaking to Dawn, an official at Allied Hospital confirmed that the suspected Ebola patient had died early on Tuesday.
According to initial reports, 40-year-old Zulfiqar Ahmed, who hailed from Punjab’s Chiniot district, was admitted to Faislabad's Allied Hospital on Saturday with high fever.
Doctors suspected that Ahmed might have contracted the deadly Ebola virus since he returned from Togo only a week ago and was bleeding from his nose and mouth.
Speaking to Dawn, Dr Rashid Maqbool at the Allied Hospital had earlier said that the patient’s blood samples had been sent to the National Institute of Health (NIH) in Islamabad for laboratory tests and it would take at least two weeks for the results to arrive.
Meanwhile, taking notice of the reports, the Punjab Health department had shifted the patient to the isolation ward at Allied Hospital.
Punjab Health Advisor Khawaja Salman Rafique had told DawnNews that government medical teams had reached Chiniot, where they would perform tests on Ahmed’s relatives and friends in case they also displayed similar symptoms.
World Health Organisation (WHO) teams are also expected to reach the Punjab town.

Acid attacks on Women




ever was a situation that could aptly be described without a trace of irony as a fate worse than death, it would be the lives of victims of acid attacks, most of whom are women.
There are few other crimes that have the kind of far-reaching, devastating and often permanent consequences in a world where physical appearance is a vital aspect of an individual’s social capital. When Pakistan’s parliament enacted the Criminal Law (Second Amendment) Act, 2011, it was hailed as an important step in the fight against this type of violence.

The legislation inserted new sections into the Pakistan Penal Code that, for the first time, defined acid attacks and stipulated imprisonment from 14 years to life and a minimum fine of Rs1m as punishment.
However, as a report in this paper yesterday indicates, that scarcely appears to have been a deterrent. In Punjab, which accounts for the majority of cases, acid attacks have actually registered an increase: there were 42 between January and September this year, compared to 35 throughout 2013.
Rights activists have persistently held that the 2011 amendment to the PPC was to have been buttressed by a comprehensive act to address various aspects of the issue — financial compensation for the victim, his/her rehabilitation, the sale of acid, etc.
Crucially, the proposed legislation recognises that victims are in need of urgent and long-term medical attention. Several drafts are in the final stages with various provincial authorities.
Among the suggestions in the draft under consideration in Punjab is that cases be processed within a specific time frame, the fine imposed upon perpetrators go towards compensation for victims and the government be made responsible for the latter’s rehabilitation.
It also stipulates the setting up of a monitoring and funding mechanism to enable effective implementation. To ensure that this most vicious of crimes does not go unpunished and that those at the receiving end are not left without redress, the comprehensive bill must be passed into law without delay.

Five ways degraded women

Five ways Pakistan degraded women

women know to expect no special concessions. At any given moment in history, one or another political force, religious edict, or social problem is aiming directly at them, pointing fingers, attaching blame. Given this, most of them expected few good things to come out of the commemoration of International Women’s Day.
Sure, there would be some laudatory articles commemorating them, a few celebrations and gatherings here and there, providing neat opportunities for politicians and dignitaries to do their smiling and clapping bit, hand out checks to widows, listen to schoolgirls sing. A history of dealing with misogyny has meant a reality of low expectations. No one, of course expected anything to actually change for the better.
A lack of hope, however, does not equal adequate preparation for catastrophe. If things were bad on women’s day, a pragmatic Pakistani woman may have assumed, they would stay in their existing state of awfulness for at least the next week. As it turns out, they were wrong.
The week after women’s day has proven that new depths of misogyny are indeed possible and that they will be achieved in Pakistan, a country resolute in being the most woman hating place on the planet. Here a list of five steps the country took in this direction.

1. Recommended child marriage

On March 11th 2014, two days after the celebration of International Women’s Day in the country, Pakistan’s Council of Islamic Ideology (perhaps fearing that women had become empowered by the occasion), decided to deliver some decisive blows.
The Chairmen of the CII, Maulana Mohammad Sheerani, declared that children below the age of puberty could be married off and that international conventions prohibiting child marriage were un-Islamic and not applicable to Pakistan. In one statement therefore, Pakistani girls, even babies were left vulnerable to abuse, with their lives and futures now liable to being decided long before they could have any say in the matter.



This was not the limit to rage against women, on an earlier day, he had also declared that any law requiring a Pakistani male to obtain permission from his first wife for a subsequent marriage, were also un-Islamic.

2. Ignored a rape victim until she burnt herself alive

She was 18 years old and she was a survivor of rape in a country where rape victims can themselves be prosecuted. Over two months earlier, on January 5, 2014, she had lodged an FIR at the police station alleging that the accused Nadir Khan, along with four accomplices had raped her near Bait Mir Hazar Chowk.
On March 13, 2014, all five men were set free. On March 14, 2014, five days after International Women’s Day, she set herself on fire outside the police station, which had so callously denied her justice. She died of her burns on the same day.

3. Buried a woman alive

Sughra Brohi of village Hakim Khan Marri in Sanghar District had committed the crime of marrying a man of her own choice. The villagepanchayat met and the elders assured everyone that she would not be killed if she returned home. They lied, As soon as she returned home, she was assaulted by her own family.
According to the Sindhi language daily, Kawish, she was buried alive in the graveyard of the Bheel community in the area. The grave was discovered and the news reported this last week. Area police are said to be investigating the case.

4. Beat up striking nurses

More than a hundred female nurses had been on strike for over five days outside the Punjab Assembly building. The nurses were protesting the firing of their colleagues who had been working on ad hoc or contract basis. On Friday March 14, 2014, the nurses all of whom were unarmed were baton charged by police.
 A policewoman beats a nurse outside the Punjab Assembly. —Photo by Online
A policewoman beats a nurse outside the Punjab Assembly. —Photo by Online
News footage of the incident showed the women being charged and heavily assaulted by law enforcement. Several were injured and had to be hospitalised, and two were so critically hurt that they had to be admitted to the intensive care unit of an area hospital.
Despite, the use of undue and unjustified force by the police, those that were unhurt continued to mark their ongoing protest outside the Assembly building.

5. Called them good for cooking not for cricket

If the round-up of being buried alive, burned to death, raped and baton charged were not plentiful degradation for Pakistani women to bear in a single week, a public insult by a man crowned the country’s cricket hero, added one more degradation to the week’s dastardly mix.



In an interview question, Shahid Afridi was asked about what he thought about the under 19 women’s cricket trials recently held in Karachi. The cricketer now revealed himself to be a male chauvinist; implying that “our women” were better kept in the kitchen, assumedly cooking up meals for their men.

With this list, the week ended, a series of blows, not unusual, not unique, but notable in their ability to represent, what is an entire nation’s inability to respect one half of its population.



In the dead and injured and degraded collected in this one week, is the reflection of a country in which every man considers himself unaccountable and unconnected to the miseries enacted every day and day after day on women.
The forces of law, of faith, of community, of Government and of entertainment, each one came together in this bouquet of misery and degradation, its stench and filth, exposing the rot that lies within.

it's time to close gender gap

it's time to close Pakistan's gender gap

Most of us men, we pay attention to rankings.
We debate and discuss rankings of our favourite teams, sports heroes, colleges, our cities, and even our countries on how they stack against the rest.
Just last week, BBC released a list, '100 Women of 2014', to highlight women working to help make a difference in the world. Six of these 100 women are either Pakistanis or of Pakistani-descent living abroad. Pakistan is clearly blessed with talented women.
Photo courtesy: BBC
Photo courtesy: BBC
But there’s another set of rankings that was released last week – a day before that BBC list.
The World Economic Forum published the Gender Gap Report 2014 on October 28, 2014. The report compiled a ranking of 142 nations on how much overall progress have women of a country made when compared to their male compatriots under a set of criteria including education, health, politics, and income.
The rankings are not too flattering. And it’s been this way for multiple years now.


Dismal gender-gap ranking


A score of 1 in the Gender Gap survey means total parity in opportunity and access between men and women for that country. The highest ranked country has a score of 0.95. Pakistan has an overall score of 0.55.
The Nordic countries of Iceland, Finland, Norway, Denmark and Sweden took the top five spots (see full rankings). Remarkably, Rwanda and Philippines made it in the top ten. Canada and United States were ranked 19th and 20th. UK was 26th. India was 114th.
Pakistan, unfortunately, ranked second to last on the list of 142 countries ahead of Yemen.

Before we roll our eyes and dismiss the rankings as culture bias, it is noteworthy that the rest of the subcontinent did not fair as poorly. Bangladesh ranked 68th – clearly in the top half of the rankings – ahead of Italy, Brazil, Russia, China, and Greece. Sri Lanka was 79th.
Gender gap rankings have a more serious implication for the social well-being of Pakistan. It reflects opportunity and access for women, which directly impacts the lives and aspirations of half of the Pakistani population.
It would be hard to claim social progress when half the population is unable to fully avail of that progress.

A silver lining


If you look at Pakistan's numbers closely for each of the four criteria i.e. income, education, health, and political empowerment, the rankings for Pakistan show up better in the category of political empowerment.
That is largely due to the fact that unlike most other nations, Pakistan has already had a female head of state.
Even though education has immense room for improvement, there is a silver lining there too. Within the small population of Pakistanis who are enrolled in universities and colleges, the ratio of men versus women is at a score of 0.95 versus an average of 0.88 for all other countries. And, that is very encouraging.

The political empowerment and higher education enrolment scores – combined with the accolades that Pakistani women are achieving on the world stage, as indicated in the BBC list – paints an encouraging picture.
In certain select segments of the population, the gender gap appears to be closing in Pakistan. In fact, women could well be outperforming men in the higher social strata of the Pakistani population.

From advanced education to economic participation


The largest gender gap, on the other hand, shows up in economic participation and opportunity – especially in professional and technical work.
So, how do we reconcile the high participation of women in higher education with their low representation in professional and technical careers?
If efforts are made to ensure that those talented young Pakistani women who are currently enrolled in higher education institutions could make a successful segue into technical and professional fields, we could well find Pakistan progressing, in terms of both gender-gap and economic output over the next generation.

Role of men in closing the gender gap


Pakistani men have a central role to play in boosting economic participation for women. Transitioning graduating women into professional careers presents one key opportunity to close the gap. Here are a few steps all of us could consider as our way of contributing:
1. Set up mentoring networks:
If we know of successful professional men or women in our friends, family or colleagues, we could encourage or facilitate mentorship. Being a role model to a college student – especially if the role model happens to be a woman – can have an immense impact in helping an aspiring student visualise a future in professional or technical work. It’s as easy as signing up to be a guest speaker or agreeing to conduct weekly phone calls to guide a female student looking for a position in the workforce.
2. Ensure equal opportunity:
As men, we find ourselves hiring or evaluating potential candidates for projects or positions on a regular basis. In such situations, we could ensure that the playing field is leveled and the environment is conducive for every candidate, whether they happen to be a man or a woman.

There’s always the chance to negotiate down the compensation for a woman since she may not be the “breadwinner” in the family or “need as much”. Fairness demands that we resist the temptation to nickel and dime based on gender.
3. Offer skills development:
In a nation with a shortage of engineers and entrepreneurs, Pakistani women represent an underused talent pool for an economy in dire need of expanding its skills base. Responsive skills development programs aimed at women would go a long way.
For those of us in a position to coach or train qualified women on technical skills, technology offers an avenue through e-learning. We don’t even need to be under the same roof as our learner. Simply post the training content on a blog, in a video lecture, or deliver over a web call using a computer connection.

Never a sure thing – but encourage success


Sometimes it does not only take skill, savvy or sacrifice to make a difference. If we are not in a position to deliver much else, then celebrating the success of women around us in their professional or technical fields can go a long way.
Competition aside, let’s be gracious when our female co-workers, colleagues, and classmates demonstrate success. And we could encourage our other male colleagues to take that view as well; workplaces could turn even more women-friendly. Caustic or hostile work environments don’t help either gender.
What if despite all of the sage advice, the efforts don’t translate into higher rankings next year for Pakistan in the Gender Gap report?
No reason to despair.

Even if it takes a while to see a closing of the gender gap, we’d still be better off having endeavoured in our personal spheres to increase economic participation for Pakistani women. Only through concerted efforts and grassroots initiatives does Pakistan stand a chance to close the gender gap.
Everyone desires higher rankings, but real men understand that it takes solid results and sustained commitment to deliver desired outcomes. Let’s not leave this agenda for the government to prioritise or a politician to promise.
Gentlemen, it’s time for us to step up and own the problem.